Docs
How we test listings
Reading the terms tells you what a service promises. Using it tells you what it does. This is the protocol we follow when we use it.
Last reviewed
Tested, Reviewed, Not reviewed
Every listing shows how deep the check behind it goes.
- Tested. Staff used the service with real money and wrote down each step. (0 of 148 listings today)
- Reviewed. Staff read the terms and public sources. Nobody has used the service for this listing yet. (148 of 148 listings today)
- Not reviewed. Suggested by a user and checked for spam only. (0 of 148 listings today)
A listing counts as Tested when sign-up (or delivery, for things without an account) and at least one more hands-on step passed within the last 365 days. After that it falls back to Reviewed until it is tested again.
The test, step by step
Each step is recorded on the listing with its date, the result and a short note. Steps that were not done are left out, not marked as passed.
1. Terms read (desk check)
Read the terms, privacy policy and FAQ. Save the pages that mention identity checks as sources.
Pass: No clause requires ID for the tested workflow. Clauses that allow ID checks are quoted on the listing.
2. Sign-up without ID
Create a fresh account (or start an order) over Tor or a VPN, with no real name, phone number or personal email.
Pass: Access works without ID, selfie, phone or a personal email.
3. Payment without ID
Pay a small real amount with the most private method listed, from a wallet with no link to an ID.
Pass: Payment is accepted and credited without an identity or source-of-funds request.
4. Service delivered
Use what was paid for: complete the swap, connect to the VPN, receive the SMS, deploy the server.
Pass: The service works as described, in the time the provider states.
5. Limits and triggers
Check the documented limits and, where it is cheap to do, repeat the action or raise the amount towards a stated threshold.
Pass: Behaviour matches the published limits. Any point where ID is requested is written down.
6. Support
Ask support a normal question from the test account.
Pass: Support answers without asking for identity documents.
7. Withdrawal or cancellation
Withdraw the funds, cancel or let the plan expire.
Pass: Money or data can be taken out without a new identity check.
Rules for testers
- Our own money, small amounts. Typically 10 to 50 USD. Providers do not pay for the test amount and do not get it back.
- No advance notice. The provider is not told a test is coming, so the tester gets the same treatment as any customer.
- A fresh, anonymous customer. New account, Tor or a VPN, no real name, no phone number, no personal email, coins with no link to an ID.
- The most private path first. If the service lists Monero or cash, that is what gets tested.
- Nothing invented. A step is marked passed only if the tester did it. Notes say what happened, without order ids or addresses.
- No favours. Testers do not accept free plans, credits or affiliate deals from the services they test.
What happens with the result
- Every run is published: the steps on the listing under Evidence, and a dated entry in events. That includes failed runs.
- If a step fails because ID was requested, the KYC level and the attributes are re-checked the same day, and the score follows from them as described in the methodology.
- A paid review can fail. Payment covers the work, not the outcome.
When we test again
- At least once every 365 days for a listing to stay Tested.
- When the terms monitor sees a source page change.
- When a credible report or several reader corrections point to a change.
A listing whose last check is older than 180 days carries a visible note, so an old result is never shown as if it were fresh.
What a test cannot show
Seen something different? Use Outdated info? on the listing. Confirmed corrections are logged publicly in the corrections log.